ChatGPT vs Claude: Why They Recommend Different Businesses
Ask ChatGPT and Claude the same question about local businesses and you will usually get two different lists. Not slightly different. Mostly different.
Over two test runs in October 2026 we asked both assistants, with live web search on, four questions a homeowner in Katy, Texas would ask: AC repair, roof repair, an emergency plumber, and water heater replacement. Between them they named 41 different companies. Only 6 were named by both.
The overlap, question by question
- AC repair in Katy: 6 companies each, 2 named by both
- Roof repair in Katy: 5 from ChatGPT, 7 from Claude, 1 named by both
- Emergency plumber in Katy: 4 from ChatGPT, 8 from Claude, 2 named by both
- Water heater replacement in Katy: 5 from ChatGPT, 6 from Claude, 1 named by both
If you run a local business, that is the headline: being recommended by one assistant tells you very little about the other. The full details are in our roofer and AC test and our plumber test.
Why the lists are so different
Neither assistant has a fixed directory of businesses. For a local question, each one searches the web, reads a handful of pages, and writes a list from what it read. Different searches lead to different pages, and different pages lead to different businesses. We saw three clear differences in how they went about it.
1. They search differently
We recorded the searches each assistant typed. ChatGPT usually ran three searches per question and kept adding detail: "24 hour", "near me", "reviews", review site names, even a zip code. Claude usually ran one or two shorter searches, such as "emergency plumber Katy TX 24 hour".
More searches means more pages read, and a wider net. Fewer, tighter searches means the first few results carry more weight.
2. They trust different kinds of pages
In the roofer and AC test, ChatGPT cited a business directory, a Reddit thread, a utility company's contractor list, review and roundup sites and Angi. Claude cited more of the contractors' own pages, plus Yelp, Angi, HomeAdvisor and a local roundup. For the emergency plumber question, Claude's eight picks all came from the plumbers' own websites.
So a business with a strong website but thin listings may do better with Claude, and a business with strong listings but a thin website may do better with ChatGPT. Most businesses need both.
3. They handle claims differently
Claude was openly cautious. It pointed out that a "best roofers in Katy" article ranked its own publisher first and treated it as promotional, and it said the 24/7 claims in its plumber answer came from the companies' own sites and were not independently verified.
ChatGPT sometimes did not give a list at all. In one of our checks, asked for the best roofer in Katy, it asked a follow-up question about the type of job before recommending anyone. A business cannot be named in an answer that names nobody, which is one more reason a single check can mislead you.
What this means for your business
Check both. Whatever you learn from one assistant, assume the other may be different. The free AI check asks ChatGPT and Claude the same question side by side.
Cover both kinds of source. Make your own pages clear and specific (service, town, hours, license, warranty) for the assistant that reads company sites, and keep your directory listings complete for the one that leans on directories and roundups. Our guide to getting your business on ChatGPT covers both.
Look at the businesses named instead of you. If a competitor is named by both, read their service pages and listings. That is what two different AI systems found convincing. Our post on which competitors AI recommends shows how to read them.
Watch it over time. Both assistants change their answers from week to week. Asking the same questions on a schedule, which is what prompt tracking does, shows you which way things are moving with each one.
Frequently asked questions
Do ChatGPT and Claude recommend the same businesses?
Usually not. In our test of four local questions they named 41 different companies between them and only 6 were named by both.
Why do ChatGPT and Claude give different recommendations?
Each one searches the web, reads a handful of pages and lists the businesses those pages describe. They run different searches and lean on different kinds of sources, so they read different pages.
Which sources does Claude use for local businesses?
In our tests Claude cited more company websites, plus Yelp, Angi, HomeAdvisor and local roundups. ChatGPT leaned more on directories, roundup sites, forum threads and contractor lists.
Should I optimize for ChatGPT or Claude?
Both. Clear, specific service pages help with the assistant that reads company sites, and complete directory listings help with the one that leans on directories. Check both and track them over time.
Does ChatGPT recommend you?
Ask ChatGPT and Claude the question your customers ask, live. Free, no account needed.
Run the Free AI Check